Start Saving to Stop Spending Money on Alternative Financial Services (AFS) - Part 2

By Megan Brewster, Coordinator to the Associate Director, and Meredith Covington, Project Director, Center for Social Development, Washington University in St. Louis.

In yesterday’s post, we examined data that show most low- to moderate-income (LMI) households who use alternative financial services are significantly worse off financially than counterparts who do not use such services. Alternative financial services include check cashing, payday loans, etc.

So what do these statistics actually mean for the household budgets of American families?

About $1,100 in fees and interest annually: That’s the average amount paid each year by unbanked LMI American households for alternative financial services. Roughly 5% of a LMI household’s annual income is spent cashing checks, managing payday loan obligations, and accessing other financial offerings from providers who are not federally insured. In purchasing power, that sum amounts to eight weeks’ worth of groceries for a family of four or rent for almost a month and a half. It’s not a small chunk of cash.

While even providers of alternative financial services themselves note their services are not a smart long-term financial solution, far too many families find themselves turning to these services again and again.

What can be done instead?

Saving – specifically, saving a tax refund—is one strategy that can help. Savings enable people to prepare financially for inevitable financial shocks like job loss and car problems and avoid turning to alternative financial services. Additionally, unlike alternative financial services providers, savings accounts with insured institutions are backed by the U.S. government, offering protection for hard-earned cash. Additionally, a savings account is also a gateway to other beneficial financial services, such as check cashing without fees.

Tax time is a golden moment for saving, as the tax refund may be the largest lump sum most LMI households receive all year. The survey data indicate that the average federal refund received by LMI users of alternative financial services was over $2,500 in 2013. Additionally, the data show that having more in savings is associated with less use of alternative financial services.

As the evidence suggests, use of alternative financial services is linked with poorer financial outcomes--but saving can limit the need for such services. Below we suggest individual strategies for prioritizing saving—one dollar at a time.

  • Save your tax refund: This season, prepare for the next financial emergency by directly depositing some or all of your refund into a savings account. If you don't have savings and something happens, you may need to take out an emergency loan; you’ll pay interest on that loan and may have to pay extra fees. To avoid those expenses and build a small cushion, consider saving some or all of your refund.
  • Make savings automatic: Research shows that saving automatically—such as by direct depositing some of your paycheck—can help to build savings quickly and without much effort. Consider establishing automatic savings.
  • Learn the strategies others use: Saving money can seem impossible, but others have found they can save if they make a plan. Read their stories and learn what could work.

Take the Pledge

I pledge to save money, reduce debt, and build wealth over time. I will encourage my family and friends to do the same

Take the America Saves Pledge

Tip of the Day

  • Written by Katie Bryan | November 25, 2013

    Tip to #save when shopping: You can #save more than 10% by comparing prices at different stores.

Saver Stories View all »

Developing a Savings "Game Plan"

Written by Katie Bryan | October 28, 2013

Eunice Diaz, a teacher in Colorado Springs, had been noticing a pattern. Despite the fact that she and her husband were “making good money,” they were spending their entire earnings and “were still struggling at the end of the month.”

Read more...

Inspired to Build Savings By Starting Small

Written by Great Lakes Michigan Saves | April 19, 2016

With little-to-no money in the bank and living on a limited income with her adult daughter, Sharon wasn’t sure if building up savings for her future was even possible. “At my age, to put debts behind me would be a relief,” she said, but she wasn’t quite sure how to even get started with a savings plan. That all changed when Sharon attended the Great Lakes Michigan Saves Pay Yourself First Saver’s Summit during America Saves Week.

Read more...

The Gift of Homeownership

Written by Tammy G. Bruzon | August 5, 2015

Quaneka Willis, a single mother of three children, was receiving rental assistance through the Housing Authority of the City of Milwaukee when she decided to take control of her finances. So, in September of 2013 she attended the Make Your Money Talk program and pledged as a Wisconsin Saver. In less than 12 months, she had maximized her savings and was beginning the process of purchasing her first home.

Read more...

Receive Updates

Sign up for Texts

Written by Tammy G. Bruzon | July 15, 2014

Sign Up

Sign up for Emails

Written by Super User | September 16, 2013

Get Emails

Take the Pledge

Written by Super User | September 16, 2013

Start Saving